In February 1992 a fund tried to buy every one of the 7,059,052 combinations in Virginia's 6-from-44 Lotto. The jackpot was $27,036,142 and a full cover cost $7,059,052, so the headline multiple was 3.83x. It looks like free money. It is a nice exercise in why a headline multiple is not a return.
Three things shrink it.
1. The prize is an annuity. The jackpot was paid in 20 equal annual instalments, the first one at once. A dollar paid in year 19 is worth much less than a dollar today.
2. Tax is withheld up front. The lottery said it would withhold 30% of each payment for federal tax and 4% for Virginia: 34% in all.
3. You may have to share. One co-winner halves the jackpot share.
Here is the whole valuation:
JACKPOT = 27_036_142 COST = 7_059_052 # one ticket per combination, $1 each WITHHOLD = 0.34 YEARS = 20 def multiple(rate, winners=1): instalment = JACKPOT / YEARS / winners pv = sum(instalment / (1 + rate) ** k for k in range(YEARS)) # first paid now return pv * (1 - WITHHOLD) / COST print(f"headline {JACKPOT / COST:.2f}x") for r in (0.06, 0.08, 0.10): print(f"sole winner @{r:.0%} {multiple(r):.2f}x") print(f"one co-winner @8% {multiple(0.08, winners=2):.2f}x") Output:
headline 3.83x sole winner @6% 1.54x sole winner @8% 1.34x sole winner @10% 1.18x one co-winner @8% 0.67x At 8%, the 3.83x headline is worth about 1.34x to a sole winner, and one co-winner turns it into a loss. Flip the function around and you get the break-even: a full cover only pays a sole winner when the jackpot is about 2.9 times the cost of every ticket, and each co-winner raises that bar again. (These ignore the smaller prizes a full cover also collects, which add a little.)
The same three-step check works for any "guaranteed" multiple: discount the cash flows, remove the frictions, then price the chance that someone else shares the payout. The fund in this story also ran out of time and bought only 5 to 5.6 million tickets, so it was never a full cover at all.
The full story, including the federal tax case it lost in 1994, is on the Betkyo Journal: https://betkyo.com/en/blog/stefan-mandel-and-the-1992-virginia-lottery-7059052-combinations-27-million-and-why-buying-every-ticket-was-a-gamble/?utm_source=devto&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=journal
Disclosure: I write for Betkyo, a crypto casino; this post was drafted with AI assistance and the numbers were checked by running the code above. 18+.