On November 20, 2026, Levent Alpöge posted a four-page note saying that he, working with Claude, believes he has found a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis (and the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis for Dirichlet L-functions). Unusually, the evidence is not a paper but a Lean formalization: 14 archive files, no human-readable write-up yet.
That raises a practical problem for anyone who wants to cite the claim responsibly: what exactly has been checked, by whom, and when? Within hours there were build reports, axiom audits, statement comparisons and expert comments scattered across Zulip, social media and news articles. I started keeping a single dated log so there is one place to point to.
What "verified" means for a Lean proof claim
A formal proof is only as good as three things, and the log tracks each of them separately:
- Does it build? Someone independent has to compile the archive with a stated Lean and Mathlib version, and ideally replay it through the kernel and through independent checkers.
- Does the main theorem say what it claims? A proof of the wrong statement is still a valid proof — of the wrong statement. The theorem should use standard definitions (here, Mathlib's own
RiemannHypothesis) and be compared against a trusted challenge file. - Which axioms does it rely on?
#print axiomsshould show only the standard ones (propext,Classical.choice,Quot.sound), with no extra axioms declared in the project.
After that come the slower, human steps: a readable write-up, expert review, broad acceptance and — eventually — the Clay Millennium Prize rules (journal publication plus two years).
How each log entry is structured
Every entry records four things:
- Event time in UTC (date only when the source gives no exact time).
- Original source — preferring primary sources: the author's note, the Lean archive, build logs, posts by the experts themselves.
- Evidence — what the source actually shows, not what it implies. Claims, readings and verifications are labelled as such.
- Status change — which verification step moved forward or back.
Each entry has a stable anchor, so articles and forum posts can link to a specific event instead of a moving page. Corrections are logged, never silently overwritten.
Where things stand (at the time of writing)
- Lean archive published — done.
- Independent build — done: an independent build reported all modules compiling with zero errors, kernel replay, and acceptance by independent checkers.
- Statement faithfulness — preliminary: automated comparison against a Mathlib-only challenge file matched; a published human audit of the statement is still pending.
- Axiom audit — done for the headline theorems (standard axioms only).
- Human-readable write-up, expert review, Clay prize — not yet.
Statuses change as evidence comes in, so check the live log rather than this snapshot.
The log
👉 Riemann Hypothesis × Claude — Verification Log
It is available in English, 简体中文, 繁體中文, 日本語, 한국어 and Français. If you have a source that adds to or contradicts an entry, the site has a corrections page.
Disclaimer: the proof is a claim under verification. The site is independent and not affiliated with Anthropic or the Clay Mathematics Institute.
