A managed service provider runs our branch network, including the routers and firewalls at all thirty eight branches. In February 2025 one of its engineers applied a firewall change at six in the morning that blocked every branch from reaching our trading system. It was found and reversed shortly after two in the afternoon. For eight hours our counters took orders on paper, and some customers went elsewhere. Finance estimated the lost margin, overtime and credit notes at a little over two hundred thousand pounds.
At the next board meeting our chief executive asked how much of that we would recover. I had to find out, and the answer was in a clause I had never read properly.
The provider's total liability for any claim in a year was capped at the charges we had paid it in the previous three months, about thirty six thousand pounds. Loss of profit, revenue and business were excluded altogether, and those made up almost all of our loss. For failures to meet the service levels, the service credits were stated to be our sole remedy, and that day earned us about four thousand pounds. Our lawyers advised that a claim for negligence would meet the same cap.
I had negotiated that contract in 2021 with our procurement team. I read the service level schedule line by line and left the liability clause to our lawyers, who reviewed it as a standard term, which it was. Nobody had asked them to compare it with what an outage would cost us, because nobody had worked that out. The board had assumed that outsourcing the network had moved the risk of it failing to someone else. Most of it had stayed with us.
Every contract for a service whose failure can stop us trading now comes to the board with a one page summary prepared with finance. It states what a day without the service would cost us, what the supplier would pay in that case, and the gap we would carry. That gap is then either covered, negotiated down or accepted by name. At its renewal this year, our network contract's cap rose to twelve months of fees, and changes to branch firewalls now need our approval before they are applied.
Outsourcing a service does not outsource the loss when it fails. The liability clause tells you how much of that loss you are still carrying, so read it with your finance director as well as your lawyer.
– Serguey Shinder


