Anyone who uses Large Language Models (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, DeepSeek) for research, analytics, or hypothesis testing knows their biggest flaw: LLMs describe a proven fact, a bold hypothesis, and a pure fabrication with the exact same smooth confidence.
When you ask an AI "Is this true?" or ask it to evaluate a controversial claim, it almost always generates a plausible-sounding essay with pros and cons. Inside a standard chat, the model lacks a hard structural brake that forces it to distinguish between:
- an event that has actually occurred and been "paid" for with real work or computation;
- a forecast with a specific verification deadline;
- an ungrounded claim with no mechanism or executor.
To solve this without building complex RAG pipelines or fine-tuning models, I developed Case Filter v1.2 — a portable, text-based verification protocol (based on the Dated Record Method) that you paste at the beginning of any chat to turn an LLM from a "plausible text generator" into a strict record auditor.
Full protocol (English & Russian) and benchmark logs on GitHub: https://github.com/IrinaVetlugina/case-filter
Core Idea: Grammatical Cases as Coordinates of a Real Transaction
The Dated Record Method treats grammatical cases not as school syntax rules, but as seven mandatory audit questions for every statement. If key coordinates are missing from a claim, we are not looking at a fact — we are looking at a logical substitution.
- Nominative ("Who is the executor?"): The debtor. Spends ticks (time, compute, resources) and acts rather than predicts.
- Accusative-Ê ("What is being created?"): The candidate or future target. Always recorded on a separate line from the actual outcome.
- Accusative-E ("What was actually created?"): The realized result of a completed act.
- Dative ("To whom is the record?"): The creditor, archive, or ownership after the transaction closes (the past).
- Genitive ("Where is the contribution from?"): The baseline record or resource funding a future act; the source of a forecast.
- Instrumental ("Paid with what? Thanks to what?"): The currency of the transaction, ticks spent, or physical/computational mechanism.
- Prepositional ("Where is the transaction?"): The institutional position or context
σ(O). Without a position, there is neither an event nor a legal record.
Two Core State Transitions
Completed Act: Ω(T) --[act σ(O)]--> E ∈ σ(O) Forecast (Pre-Act): Ω(T) --[act σ(O)]--> Ê ∈ σ(O) --[verification]--> E Strict Protocol Rules for the AI:
- Banned certainty words: The LLM is strictly prohibited from using words like "confirmed", "proven", or "truth". It may only assign strict protocol statuses:
legal record,[R] candidate,left edge,cell 1(record without act), orfalse removed. - Dated verification windows: A candidate
Êis valid only prior to the act and only with a dated verification window. - Legitimizing "I don't know": When external verification criteria are missing, the AI is forbidden from guessing and must assign
unidentified remainder. - Role separation: The AI acts strictly as the
carrier: AI(and must label every card as such), while the human user remains the "key holder" responsible for time-based verification.
Benchmark Experiment: Running 10 Major Science Problems
To test the filter's discipline on complex, ambiguous claims, I ran 10 fundamental problems across different fields of science through the protocol — 2 solved and 8 unsolved (full log available in run-science-problems-en.md in the repository).
Crucial rule: the tool does not attempt to "solve" equations for scientists — it audits the status of records about them.
1. Solved Problems → legal record
When auditing the Poincaré Conjecture and Protein Folding (AlphaFold2), the model moved both records into the Dative case as established facts, because both presented paid computational/mathematical ticks and closed external verification windows:
RECORD: Poincaré Conjecture solved (every simply connected, closed 3-manifold is homeomorphic to the 3-sphere). FRAMEWORK Ω(T): 3-manifold topology; parameter T absent (timeless mathematical framework) ACT: completed; paid with mathematical ticks of Ricci flow with surgery (2002–2003) and independent verification (2006); crossed the creator's boundary POSITION σ(O): corpus of mathematical knowledge (preprint archives, peer-reviewed publications) CLASS: legal record VERIFICATION WINDOW: closed (verified in 2003–2006, Ê = E) FORECAST Ê: removed (returned to Dative case as fact) ERRORS: none detected SUBJECT IN PROTOCOL: omitted (Rule 4 of Chair Laws) carrier: AI 2. Unsolved Problems with a Theoretical Contribution → left edge
For the Riemann Hypothesis, Navier–Stokes Existence and Smoothness, P vs NP, Abiogenesis, and Linear A Decipherment, the protocol assigned left edge (or [R] candidate for Quantum Gravity). A foundational contribution exists, but the final act has not been paid with ticks and no dated verification window exists:
RECORD: Riemann Hypothesis (all non-trivial zeros of the Riemann zeta function have real part 1/2). FRAMEWORK Ω(T): analytic number theory; parameter T absent (timeless frame) ACT: not completed (no general proof; partial numerical checks of billions of zeros do not close the general framework) POSITION σ(O): corpus of mathematics (Clay Mathematics Institute, Millennium Prize Problems) CLASS: left edge VERIFICATION WINDOW: absent (no dated window for the general case) FORECAST Ê: issued without window (contribution since 1859 without final act) ERRORS: none detected SUBJECT IN PROTOCOL: omitted (Rule 4 of Chair Laws) carrier: AI 3. Problems Lacking External Criteria → unidentified remainder
The most revealing result came on the Nature of Dark Matter and the Hard Problem of Consciousness (how physical brain processes generate subjective experience / qualia). Instead of summarizing popular theories as an answer, the AI legally refused to classify them:
RECORD: Hard Problem of Consciousness (how and why physical processes in the brain give rise to subjective experience / qualia). FRAMEWORK Ω(T): philosophy of mind and neurobiology; parameter T — timescale of neural correlates ACT: not completed (objective neural ticks are measured, but the transition from physical process to subjective experience is neither described nor measured) POSITION σ(O): corpus of neuroscience and philosophy of mind (conflicting positions) CLASS: unidentified remainder VERIFICATION WINDOW: absent (no operational criterion for external verification of subjective experience) FORECAST Ê: absent (cannot issue a legal forecast without verification criterion E) ERRORS: none detected SUBJECT IN PROTOCOL: omitted (Rule 4 of Chair Laws) carrier: AI Quick Start (30 Seconds)
No libraries, plugins, or API keys required:
Open the repository: https://github.com/IrinaVetlugina/case-filter
Copy the entire contents of
case-filter-v1.2-en.md(orcase-filter-v1.2.mdfor Russian).Paste it at the very beginning of a new chat with any modern LLM (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, DeepSeek, etc.).
Submit any claim, news item, or working hypothesis using:
RUN: [your claim here] Useful Session Commands
-
RUN: [text]— audit a record and output a strict protocol card + brief explanation. -
FORECAST: [Ê] window [date]— register a hypothesis prior to its verification deadline. -
VERIFY: [Ê against fact E]— verify a prediction once the window arrives. -
SUMMARY— self-audit the AI carrier for classification/reading errors (O1–O3) during the session.
Limitations & Honest Accounting
To get real value from the protocol, keep three boundaries in mind:
- It audits records, not primary reality. The filter exposes hidden passive voice ("it happened on its own"), missing mechanisms, and unverified forecasts, but it does not run lab experiments or fact-check raw numbers for you.
- Input sensitivity. At boundary zones (e.g., between
[R] candidateandleft edge), missing explicit timelines in the prompt can cause classification slips (O1 error), which is why the human always remains the "key holder." - Context drift in long chats. Like any system prompt, over dozens of messages an LLM may loosen its card formatting — simply run
SUMMARYor start a fresh chat with the carrier file.
License & Repository
**GitHub Repository: https://github.com/IrinaVetlugina/case-filter
License: Deposited with n'RIS (Reg. No.
852-137-831dated20.11.2026). Free for individuals for personal, educational, and non-commercial research use; commercial license agreement required for organizations and businesses.
I'd love to hear your feedback — try running a controversial claim, startup pitch, or research hypothesis through the filter and share what status your LLM assigns!