The name "Wingdings" covers four fonts with four different mappings, and that is the source of most decoding mistakes.
Wingdings 1 is the original 1992 font: faces, hands, mail, weather, stars. Wingdings 2 adds a large set of check marks, boxes, arrows and geometric shapes, which is why people looking for a tick often find it there rather than in the first font. Wingdings 3 is almost entirely arrows and directional symbols. Webdings, from 1997, is the odd one out: houses, tools, transport, spiders, interface icons — a web-era vocabulary rather than a general-purpose one.
The practical consequence: you cannot apply the wrong family and expect a plausible result. The same key produces unrelated symbols in each, and the output looks like a valid message either way. That is why identification comes before decoding.
If you have a block of symbols and no context, try each family through the Wingdings decoder until the English makes sense. For reference, the full chart covers all four fonts side by side, and the Webdings page lists that font's mapping in full. Once you know the family, everything else is a lookup.