AI & ML
Fragmented Markers, Mixed Results: A Systematic Review of AI Coding Assistants and Developer Productivity
arXiv cs.SE0 views
arXiv:2611.21632v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: AI coding assistants are increasingly embedded in software engineering practice, yet the literature still offers no cumulative, easily interpretable picture of their effects on software developer productivity. The central problem is not a lack of studies, but a lack of comparability: prior work operationalizes productivity through heterogeneous markers, settings, and reporting styles, making cross-study conclusions difficult. To address this, we conduct a staged systematic literature review. In the first stage, we synthesize studies that explicitly examine developer productivity. In the second, we extend the scope to productivity-related developer outcomes using SPACE as a theory-informed lens, capturing human-centered evidence that explicit productivity studies often omit. Across both stages, we analyze how productivity is operationalized, which confounding factors are discussed, and how reported effects are distributed. We identify 187 unique productivity and productivity-related markers, while individual studies typically only use five, revealing a broad but highly fragmented evidence base. Explicit productivity research is dominated by time-, output-, and artifact-oriented proxies, whereas the broader SPACE-aligned corpus makes satisfaction, psychological aspects, and well-being substantially more visible. Reported effects are often positive, but this pattern is stronger in perceived and tendency-based findings than in objective or statistically evaluated ones. Overall, the literature suggests that AI coding assistants can support productivity, but current evidence does not yet support simple, context-independent conclusions. The key contribution of this review is therefore a structured basis for making productivity evidence more interpretable, multidimensional, and comparable across studies.
Source:https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.21632PreviousA Model-Driven Automation Pipeline for Building OperationNextMeasuring Human-AI Alignment as an Early Indicator for Effective Collaboration in Hybrid SE Teams
Related posts
TacBridge: Learning Unified Tactile Representations through Cross-Sensor Correspondence
0arXiv cs.RO
Transferable Neural CBFs via Generalized Closure
0arXiv cs.RO
QTOP: Scaling Humanoid Motion Tracking with Quantile Critics
0arXiv cs.RO
Non-Imaging Optical Tactile Sensors for Robotics: Transduction Principles, System Integration, and Robotic Applications
0arXiv cs.RO
Robotic Reward Models in the Foundation-Model Era
0arXiv cs.RO
Selective Sensor Acquisition for Multimodal Place Recognition
0arXiv cs.RO