I finally went through a box of old CDs last month, and the first thing I hit was the classic problem: I copied the tracks to my desktop, tried to convert them, and got nothing. If that happened to you too, here is what is going on and the routine that worked.

Why the .cda files don't convert

Open an audio CD in File Explorer and you see Track01.cda, Track02.cda and so on. Each one is about 44 bytes. They are not audio at all, just pointers that tell the computer where a track starts and ends on the disc. The music lives as raw CD audio that only ripping software can read straight from the drive. So copying .cda files and feeding them to any converter, online or offline, will never work. You have to rip the disc.

What you need

  • A CD drive. Most new laptops and Macs don't have one, but a cheap external USB drive is fine.
  • Ripping software you probably already have: Windows Media Player Legacy on Windows, or the Music app on a Mac.
  • Some patience if the discs are scratched. Clean them from the centre outwards with a soft cloth before ripping.

Settings that actually matter

Windows: in Windows Media Player Legacy, open Rip settings, set Format to MP3 and Audio quality to 256 or 320 kbps, then click Rip CD.

Mac: in Music, go to Settings > Files > Import Settings, choose MP3 Encoder and Higher Quality (192 kbps) or a custom 256 kbps, then insert the disc and click Import CD.

For music, I'd stay at 256 kbps or higher. Storage is cheap and you only want to rip each disc once. If you want a full walkthrough, including the legal side and fixes for skipped tracks, this guide on how to rip a CD to MP3 and why .cda files won't convert goes through Windows and Mac step by step.

Already ripped to WAV or FLAC?

If you ripped years ago to WAV or FLAC, keep those as your archive and make MP3 copies for the phone or car. Any converter works. A browser-based one like this FLAC to MP3 converter does it without installing anything.

Disclosure: Convertola is our own project, so I'm biased. It doesn't read CDs itself, it only converts files you have already ripped.

A workflow for a big collection

  1. Check that track names come through correctly (both apps look them up online) before you rip a whole stack.
  2. Rip one disc, play a couple of tracks all the way through, then batch the rest.
  3. Keep one folder per album: Artist/Album/01 Title.mp3.
  4. Back up the folder before you give the discs away.

Common problems

  • Clicks or skips: clean the disc and rip again, or try another drive. Some drives handle scratches much better than others.
  • "Track 1, Track 2" names: the online lookup failed. Fix the tags afterwards with a tag editor.
  • Car stereo won't play the files: use plain MP3 at a constant bitrate and a FAT32-formatted USB stick.

That's it. An afternoon with a USB drive and the right settings turns a shelf of discs into a library you can actually use.