A finished check means the argument typechecks. It does not mean you understand it.

Levent Alpöge says he and Claude formalized a proof of the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis, without assumptions. He also says he has not mastered the mathematics sitting around that argument.

He says the formalization is finished. Turning it into a huge document with sufficient detail is, in his account, routine. He amused himself and got past 250,000 pages. Claude called the pile a book.

Theorem 1 opens by noting that the real numbers are totally ordered. If a number is not one half, it is bigger, or it is smaller. A checker will spend a page saying so. That is how you know a human never edited it for a reader.

He did not post the pile. He says posting that unreadable dump would be inappropriate. He published the Lean instead, in fourteen parts.

He is showing a complete argument before he has mastered a large neighborhood of it. The files are ahead of the author.

Where Claude did the technical work, his timeline is a paraphrase of a summary he warns may make no sense. He points at the Lean. He says he is too inexpert there to explain it himself.

His instinct is that the argument will get much simpler, and soon. He has not had time to find that shorter version. He calls this one step. The unpaid work is to understand it, simplify it, talk about it, and write it properly.

Same trap as a generated patch you cannot walk someone through. The green run is not the tour.

Skip these:

  • Counting a finished checker run as the writeup.
  • Posting the generated document because it has sufficient detail.
  • Paraphrasing a region you do not know, then hiding behind the artifact.
  • Reading "nothing left open in the file" as "I can teach this."
  • Shipping the archive today and filing the explanation under later.

The Lean can check out while you are still late to your own result.

A green build is permission to start explaining. It is not permission to stop.

Source

HN discussion

This post was generated automatically from public Hacker News data.